Showing posts with label super long blog post. Show all posts
Showing posts with label super long blog post. Show all posts
Friday, April 26, 2013
86 Things I've Said On Twitter, the 9th and final part
This summary is not available. Please
click here to view the post.
Wednesday, January 23, 2013
How You Can Use Fate Core to Write/Design A Game
Yesterday I wrote about how you can use Fate Core to write a novel. Today, I'm going to tell you how you can use Fate Core to write a game, or a setting, or a scenario, or a campaign...even if that game doesn't use Fate.
Now, I know what you're thinking - that sounds crazy. But really it's not. We're just going to look at the applications of what we talked about yesterday, and leave the mechanical constructs (fate point economy, dice rolling, etc) to the side for now, else we'll muddy waters and confuse people (including myself).
Note though, this is how I design things, and my design style may be an entirely different approach than what you do, what you like or how you go about even starting it. I say this not to ward you off, but rather tell you to make this method your own, and that you're free to change elements to suit your tastes, rather than clone me.
A brief overview is in order:
1. Characters and scenes have aspects.
2. There are four actions - overcome, create an advantage, attack, defend
(see, wasn't kidding when I said that was brief)
To start this discussion, we have to pick a thing we're making. Let's say you're making something that you can run with your weekly group, but something that if you polished it up enough, you may consider releasing for profit if all goes well. This way, we'll keep the conversation "local" and free from business-y distractions.
Now we take our first steps and decide what sort of genre this game is going to be in. Will it be steampunk? Will it be swords and sorcery? Will it feature struggles against zombies?
Step 1:: If you haven't already, write down 1 sentence or phrase (try and center it on the topmost line of the legal pad, if you're like me) that summarizes the experience of this yet-untitled-game.
Here's one straight from my little blue notebook of designs --
Already from this one sentence expression we can pull out concrete requirements for the game. Mine will need a prison to escape from, some badguys to catch, and good guys (the players) who will try to clear their names (suggestive of drama, tension and investigation).
Yours may have aliens, trolls, clowns, goat-bartering or vampires. Whatever you've got on your paper, look for the concrete elements. If your sentence doesn't have any, give it more thought, and write a different sentence.
When you've gotten that down on paper, we go forward.
Step 2:: For each concrete thing you can pull out of that sentence, create three to five aspects for each element.
For mine, I divide the legal pad into 3 columns: Prison, Badguys, PCs
Note: I don't want to dictate what aspects the PCs have - because I want my players to have some creative ability and input in my game. But I can create a loose framework for what sort of aspects work best...essentially crafting boundaries for the field the players operate on, and later (as we'll see) giving me sentences that I can use to describe the game to others.
Prison
Formidable
Thought to be inescapable
Made of the best materials available
Heavily guarded
Wretched hive of scum and villainy
Badguys
Veterans of crime
Scarred and broken people
Rough and tumble
Thick
Hungry
Players
Innocents among the guilty
Never going back
Always on the run
Schemers, Fighters and Planners
Adjusting to life on the outside
Step 3:: Using the Aspects as a reference, apply your mechanical base to your elements In my case, that's NPC(s) and location(s).
Here is a point where we may go down radically different paths. Depending on what mechanical engine you're using, this step might take some time. That's okay, this process isn't quick. Think about how you've described the elements of your game, and using your best judgment, convert the words into numbers.
If the Prison is formidable, how many feet thick are the walls? Does your game have an armor rating? Maybe the walls rate a large number. If the badguys are veterans of crime, just how good are they at the criminal skillset your game may have?
When this step is done, you should have stats for some of the components of the thing you're creating. Over time, as you give this more thought and as we get to applying the four actions, you can flesh out the rest of the stats.
Step 4:: Find the adventure's best starting point.
Whether you've got adventurers meeting in a tavern, intrepid reporters responding to a Craigslist ad, or a bunch of mercenaries gathered on Gamma Beta Seven, every adventure has a starting point. Now if this adventure is a campaign, then we're looking for this "episode's" best starting point.
Starting points are most often exposition dumps, where everyone goes around the table and says who and what their character is, and it can be WAY boring. There are ways around it, by intermingling the backstories of characters (as in Fate games) or by withholding backstories and focusing on the task at hand (as is done in Call of Cthulhu). Keep an eye out for boredom generators (far too much talking, not enough doing, the players don't engage the mechanics right away), and the adventure can start before you know it.
Step 5:: Map out the adventure, using the four actions of Fate.
Every type of scene the players get into can be expressed as one of the four actions.
Overcome Scenes are those scenes where there are skill-based challenges or puzzles that require the players make use of the mechanics of the game. This could be a sphinx's riddle, orchestrating a jailbreak, sweet-talking guards instead of fighting them, or anything where a player uses skills or abilities against opposition but doesn't get into combat.
Advantage Scenes (scenes where the players create an advantage) are those scenes where players use the environment or story detail to improve their situation(s). A super scientist spending time in the lab to create power armor, a thief spending time with the local guild, a cop shaking down informants -- all are situations created because the world/environment of the game has made them possible. Yes, the line may blur a little between overcome and advantage scenes, but to distinguish between the two, look at your focus -- is the focus on the skill-check? Then it's an overcome scene. If the focus is on the end result, or you're likely to handwave the roll, then it's an advantage scene.
Attack Scenes are combat, most often initiated by the players, where they brandish sword, fists or guns and take on enemy forces. Most often the climax of an adventure is an attack scene or "boss fight". It doesn't have to be that way, if your game centers more on investigation (as in Gumshoe) or in self-discovery ("I learned something new about myself!"), then your climaxes aren't going to be fight-y. Attack scenes are also opportunities for the mechanics of your system to be tested, so if you're home-brewing, make sure your combative ducks are in a row.
Defense Scenes (scenes where players Defend) are NOT just part of combat. Yes, defense is inherent in combat, as a reaction to a fighting action, but Defense scenes can also lay the groundwork and advantages for future scenes. In an investigative game, these scenes pit clues against reality - as players work to rectify what they know already with new information just acquired (it was old man Jenkins who killed Robbie!) Defense outside of a combat scene is most often a narrative experience, giving characters a chance to explore feelings, situations and experiences to find their place in-game.
There is no standard formula for how many of each scene you have to have, or that every sixth scene must be a combat. But there is a progression within a story of scenes, as tensions rise and build to climax.
Often, Attack scenes sit atop the pyramid, having been set up by Overcome Scenes and Defense Scenes, all predicated on the work established in Advantage Scenes, and lesser Overcome Scenes.
Let's come back to the earlier prison game example...
I want my players to start by escaping from prison (Overcome scene), possibly fighting their way out as needed (Attack scene), and making their way to an established safehouse (Advantage scene). From there they'll investigate the crime that sent them to prison (Overcome scenes, Advantage scenes, Defense scenes), ultimately confronting the real villains (Attack scene) and getting them to confess before escaping the pursuing prison forces (Defense scene, Advantage scene).
That's episode one of my campaign, or if this is a one-shot deal, that's the adventure as a whole.
Step 6:: Prepare anything you may have missed, now that you have an outline.
Going now scene by scene, give each scene the needed details. Write in those clues for the investigators to find. Fluff up that flavor text that you can read to players so they'll know what to expect. Make sure any opposition the PCs will face has proper stats and equipment and make sure any treasure available is appropriately balanced (or wildly off-balance, if that's your preference). This is also a chance to read over the work as a whole and make sure that scenes connect to each other, either for narrative reasons (one scene comes as a result of the previous) or mechanical reasons (you need a hospital after getting beaten near to death).
Step 7:: Go play your game.
Enjoy yourself. Change whatever you need to, on the fly, to make sure you have the best time possible. It doesn't matter that the players totally skipped the sweet action you had planned on page 4, the bottom line is always this -- have the best time possible with your friends. Rules and games change accordingly.
See you next time, happy writing and gaming.
Now, I know what you're thinking - that sounds crazy. But really it's not. We're just going to look at the applications of what we talked about yesterday, and leave the mechanical constructs (fate point economy, dice rolling, etc) to the side for now, else we'll muddy waters and confuse people (including myself).
Note though, this is how I design things, and my design style may be an entirely different approach than what you do, what you like or how you go about even starting it. I say this not to ward you off, but rather tell you to make this method your own, and that you're free to change elements to suit your tastes, rather than clone me.
A brief overview is in order:
1. Characters and scenes have aspects.
2. There are four actions - overcome, create an advantage, attack, defend
(see, wasn't kidding when I said that was brief)
To start this discussion, we have to pick a thing we're making. Let's say you're making something that you can run with your weekly group, but something that if you polished it up enough, you may consider releasing for profit if all goes well. This way, we'll keep the conversation "local" and free from business-y distractions.
Now we take our first steps and decide what sort of genre this game is going to be in. Will it be steampunk? Will it be swords and sorcery? Will it feature struggles against zombies?
Step 1:: If you haven't already, write down 1 sentence or phrase (try and center it on the topmost line of the legal pad, if you're like me) that summarizes the experience of this yet-untitled-game.
Here's one straight from my little blue notebook of designs --
Prison escape, investigation and catching of real culprits
Already from this one sentence expression we can pull out concrete requirements for the game. Mine will need a prison to escape from, some badguys to catch, and good guys (the players) who will try to clear their names (suggestive of drama, tension and investigation).
Yours may have aliens, trolls, clowns, goat-bartering or vampires. Whatever you've got on your paper, look for the concrete elements. If your sentence doesn't have any, give it more thought, and write a different sentence.
When you've gotten that down on paper, we go forward.
Step 2:: For each concrete thing you can pull out of that sentence, create three to five aspects for each element.
For mine, I divide the legal pad into 3 columns: Prison, Badguys, PCs
Note: I don't want to dictate what aspects the PCs have - because I want my players to have some creative ability and input in my game. But I can create a loose framework for what sort of aspects work best...essentially crafting boundaries for the field the players operate on, and later (as we'll see) giving me sentences that I can use to describe the game to others.
Prison
Formidable
Thought to be inescapable
Made of the best materials available
Heavily guarded
Wretched hive of scum and villainy
Badguys
Veterans of crime
Scarred and broken people
Rough and tumble
Thick
Hungry
Players
Innocents among the guilty
Never going back
Always on the run
Schemers, Fighters and Planners
Adjusting to life on the outside
Step 3:: Using the Aspects as a reference, apply your mechanical base to your elements In my case, that's NPC(s) and location(s).
Here is a point where we may go down radically different paths. Depending on what mechanical engine you're using, this step might take some time. That's okay, this process isn't quick. Think about how you've described the elements of your game, and using your best judgment, convert the words into numbers.
If the Prison is formidable, how many feet thick are the walls? Does your game have an armor rating? Maybe the walls rate a large number. If the badguys are veterans of crime, just how good are they at the criminal skillset your game may have?
When this step is done, you should have stats for some of the components of the thing you're creating. Over time, as you give this more thought and as we get to applying the four actions, you can flesh out the rest of the stats.
Step 4:: Find the adventure's best starting point.
Whether you've got adventurers meeting in a tavern, intrepid reporters responding to a Craigslist ad, or a bunch of mercenaries gathered on Gamma Beta Seven, every adventure has a starting point. Now if this adventure is a campaign, then we're looking for this "episode's" best starting point.
Starting points are most often exposition dumps, where everyone goes around the table and says who and what their character is, and it can be WAY boring. There are ways around it, by intermingling the backstories of characters (as in Fate games) or by withholding backstories and focusing on the task at hand (as is done in Call of Cthulhu). Keep an eye out for boredom generators (far too much talking, not enough doing, the players don't engage the mechanics right away), and the adventure can start before you know it.
Step 5:: Map out the adventure, using the four actions of Fate.
Every type of scene the players get into can be expressed as one of the four actions.
Overcome Scenes are those scenes where there are skill-based challenges or puzzles that require the players make use of the mechanics of the game. This could be a sphinx's riddle, orchestrating a jailbreak, sweet-talking guards instead of fighting them, or anything where a player uses skills or abilities against opposition but doesn't get into combat.
Advantage Scenes (scenes where the players create an advantage) are those scenes where players use the environment or story detail to improve their situation(s). A super scientist spending time in the lab to create power armor, a thief spending time with the local guild, a cop shaking down informants -- all are situations created because the world/environment of the game has made them possible. Yes, the line may blur a little between overcome and advantage scenes, but to distinguish between the two, look at your focus -- is the focus on the skill-check? Then it's an overcome scene. If the focus is on the end result, or you're likely to handwave the roll, then it's an advantage scene.
Attack Scenes are combat, most often initiated by the players, where they brandish sword, fists or guns and take on enemy forces. Most often the climax of an adventure is an attack scene or "boss fight". It doesn't have to be that way, if your game centers more on investigation (as in Gumshoe) or in self-discovery ("I learned something new about myself!"), then your climaxes aren't going to be fight-y. Attack scenes are also opportunities for the mechanics of your system to be tested, so if you're home-brewing, make sure your combative ducks are in a row.
Defense Scenes (scenes where players Defend) are NOT just part of combat. Yes, defense is inherent in combat, as a reaction to a fighting action, but Defense scenes can also lay the groundwork and advantages for future scenes. In an investigative game, these scenes pit clues against reality - as players work to rectify what they know already with new information just acquired (it was old man Jenkins who killed Robbie!) Defense outside of a combat scene is most often a narrative experience, giving characters a chance to explore feelings, situations and experiences to find their place in-game.
There is no standard formula for how many of each scene you have to have, or that every sixth scene must be a combat. But there is a progression within a story of scenes, as tensions rise and build to climax.
Often, Attack scenes sit atop the pyramid, having been set up by Overcome Scenes and Defense Scenes, all predicated on the work established in Advantage Scenes, and lesser Overcome Scenes.
Let's come back to the earlier prison game example...
I want my players to start by escaping from prison (Overcome scene), possibly fighting their way out as needed (Attack scene), and making their way to an established safehouse (Advantage scene). From there they'll investigate the crime that sent them to prison (Overcome scenes, Advantage scenes, Defense scenes), ultimately confronting the real villains (Attack scene) and getting them to confess before escaping the pursuing prison forces (Defense scene, Advantage scene).
That's episode one of my campaign, or if this is a one-shot deal, that's the adventure as a whole.
Step 6:: Prepare anything you may have missed, now that you have an outline.
Going now scene by scene, give each scene the needed details. Write in those clues for the investigators to find. Fluff up that flavor text that you can read to players so they'll know what to expect. Make sure any opposition the PCs will face has proper stats and equipment and make sure any treasure available is appropriately balanced (or wildly off-balance, if that's your preference). This is also a chance to read over the work as a whole and make sure that scenes connect to each other, either for narrative reasons (one scene comes as a result of the previous) or mechanical reasons (you need a hospital after getting beaten near to death).
Step 7:: Go play your game.
Enjoy yourself. Change whatever you need to, on the fly, to make sure you have the best time possible. It doesn't matter that the players totally skipped the sweet action you had planned on page 4, the bottom line is always this -- have the best time possible with your friends. Rules and games change accordingly.
See you next time, happy writing and gaming.
Thursday, December 20, 2012
The Ecstasy Of Hope
I write this post on the eve of the possible Mayan apocalypse and days before Christmas. I've prepared for both. (Translation: I bought snacks and am wearing a bathrobe). This is also the time of year people look back and reflect on what they've done - highlighting successes and distributing pats upon backs. I want to do that too, only I'm also going to look forward.
On The Editing Fronts
2012 was a HUGE year for me. My first works as an editor went out into peoples' hands. I attended my first GenCon. I was welcomed not as an outsider but as a friend upon my return to conventions. I had my hand in a lot of products, everything from vampires to wizards to comic book heroes. And that makes me tremendously happy.
2013 looks to be even bigger, though the number of projects I can tell you I'm involved in is larger, I just can't yet give up any details or specifics. I know, that's like a weird teasing move, and I don't mean it to be, but you're going to be amazed by quite a few projects that will be out in the coming year.
Okay, twist my arm. Here's a taste --> vampires, wizards, comic book heroes, lots of kickstarter-y goodness. (yeah, that's more of the same from 2012)
On The Writing Fronts
I made a big shift this year to get away from writing and move into editing, creating and helping produce other people's work. Part of that was a time decision, but it was also carefully made decision to play to my strengths and my happiness. I love to write, I still think I'm good at it, but I think I'm better at editing. (Though editing contains its own share of writing - it's different: writing for a purpose than writing for yourself)
It was not an easy decision, and contrary to what a lot of people may believe, not an economic one. As I'll talk about below, 2012 was the year I found out what it's like to be happy, and happy became the new currency of the realm.
So writing became the back-burner, with editing and consulting taking on a larger and more important role. Rather than being the somewhat clueless writer who occasionally edits, I'm the far savvier editor who sometimes writes. The shift in identity has been huge for me.
On The Personal Fronts
Wow, what a year. To put it bluntly, everything changed this year. I got my head screwed on straight, and I took steps towards being the kind of person I always used to talk about being - now I just am that guy. It's loads easier, far less stressful and I get to focus on the things that make me happy, rather than pander to other people and their goals that may lead me to being unhappy. A huge weight came off my shoulders and for the first time in about half my life, I have a sense of who and what I am. It's very empowering.
I feel less alien, less disconnected to people (though at times I will totally admit to being somewhat lost) and more comfortable as myself. I look for this to continue in 2013. Go me.
The Future
I want the Pay What You Want / What It's Worth workshops to really take off. I want them to be a success. Not because I expect to make a truckload of money, because I'm not in this for the money, I'm doing this to share my passion, expertise and joy at helping writers come out from behind their shields and out from under rocks so that they can discover truly who and what they are. And make them better.
There's not a gimmick here, I'm not doing this to trick people, I'm going to offer whoever wants it a chance to get better, at whatever price-point works for them and their budget. There's a measure of honesty involved here, because people could very easily get jaded and just hand me a dollar, but if that's really what my time is worth to them, then chances are I'm not really going to change their minds, am I?
Also going forward, I'm going to work really hard at keeping my personal life (things not related to work and craft) off this blog. I am the occasional over-sharer, and have realized that it's not fair to other people to have what they may consider personal anecdotes or statements shared with the world at large. Hope you don't mind.
So what do I want out of the future? I want to continue going forward and up the path towards more success. More recognition. More talking about the process of editing and writing. More helping people. More getting good games and books and projects out to people who enjoy them.
I have the greatest respect for my colleagues, peers and friends, and it would be a travesty to not mention them here. A very large dose of gratitude, thanks, appreciation, and respect go to (in no order) Amanda Valentine, Ryan Macklin, Lillian Cohen-Moore, Brian Engard, Fred Hicks, Rob Donoghue, Shoshana Kessock, Cam Banks, Ken Hite, Jeremy Morgan, Brianna Reed, Jenn Steen, and the doubtless others I am forgetting to mention and link to. It would not have been the year it was without you in my life to some capacity. Thank you so much, for everything.
2013 is going to be amazing.
Happy writing
On The Editing Fronts
2012 was a HUGE year for me. My first works as an editor went out into peoples' hands. I attended my first GenCon. I was welcomed not as an outsider but as a friend upon my return to conventions. I had my hand in a lot of products, everything from vampires to wizards to comic book heroes. And that makes me tremendously happy.
2013 looks to be even bigger, though the number of projects I can tell you I'm involved in is larger, I just can't yet give up any details or specifics. I know, that's like a weird teasing move, and I don't mean it to be, but you're going to be amazed by quite a few projects that will be out in the coming year.
Okay, twist my arm. Here's a taste --> vampires, wizards, comic book heroes, lots of kickstarter-y goodness. (yeah, that's more of the same from 2012)
On The Writing Fronts
I made a big shift this year to get away from writing and move into editing, creating and helping produce other people's work. Part of that was a time decision, but it was also carefully made decision to play to my strengths and my happiness. I love to write, I still think I'm good at it, but I think I'm better at editing. (Though editing contains its own share of writing - it's different: writing for a purpose than writing for yourself)
It was not an easy decision, and contrary to what a lot of people may believe, not an economic one. As I'll talk about below, 2012 was the year I found out what it's like to be happy, and happy became the new currency of the realm.
So writing became the back-burner, with editing and consulting taking on a larger and more important role. Rather than being the somewhat clueless writer who occasionally edits, I'm the far savvier editor who sometimes writes. The shift in identity has been huge for me.
On The Personal Fronts
Wow, what a year. To put it bluntly, everything changed this year. I got my head screwed on straight, and I took steps towards being the kind of person I always used to talk about being - now I just am that guy. It's loads easier, far less stressful and I get to focus on the things that make me happy, rather than pander to other people and their goals that may lead me to being unhappy. A huge weight came off my shoulders and for the first time in about half my life, I have a sense of who and what I am. It's very empowering.
I feel less alien, less disconnected to people (though at times I will totally admit to being somewhat lost) and more comfortable as myself. I look for this to continue in 2013. Go me.
The Future
I want the Pay What You Want / What It's Worth workshops to really take off. I want them to be a success. Not because I expect to make a truckload of money, because I'm not in this for the money, I'm doing this to share my passion, expertise and joy at helping writers come out from behind their shields and out from under rocks so that they can discover truly who and what they are. And make them better.
There's not a gimmick here, I'm not doing this to trick people, I'm going to offer whoever wants it a chance to get better, at whatever price-point works for them and their budget. There's a measure of honesty involved here, because people could very easily get jaded and just hand me a dollar, but if that's really what my time is worth to them, then chances are I'm not really going to change their minds, am I?
Also going forward, I'm going to work really hard at keeping my personal life (things not related to work and craft) off this blog. I am the occasional over-sharer, and have realized that it's not fair to other people to have what they may consider personal anecdotes or statements shared with the world at large. Hope you don't mind.
So what do I want out of the future? I want to continue going forward and up the path towards more success. More recognition. More talking about the process of editing and writing. More helping people. More getting good games and books and projects out to people who enjoy them.
I have the greatest respect for my colleagues, peers and friends, and it would be a travesty to not mention them here. A very large dose of gratitude, thanks, appreciation, and respect go to (in no order) Amanda Valentine, Ryan Macklin, Lillian Cohen-Moore, Brian Engard, Fred Hicks, Rob Donoghue, Shoshana Kessock, Cam Banks, Ken Hite, Jeremy Morgan, Brianna Reed, Jenn Steen, and the doubtless others I am forgetting to mention and link to. It would not have been the year it was without you in my life to some capacity. Thank you so much, for everything.
2013 is going to be amazing.
Happy writing
Wednesday, July 11, 2012
Storytelling!
You could also call this article "Game Mastering" or "Game Running" or "How To Build A Better Novel" or "How To Take An Idea Out Of Your Head And Put It Into A Form People Will Enjoy"
On Monday, I talked about what I learned from running a tournament game over the weekend at DexCon. The experience left such a clear impression in my mind, and really affected me that I'm going to continue talking about it today.
But whereas on Monday I was praising the people I worked with and the specific stories told, I didn't really
talk at all about HOW those things came into being. I don't mean "We exchanged emails" I mean "how did I take the notes I got (which were little paragraphs of or 3 sentences) and turn them into 7 ten-page relatively complete and interlocking experiences?
To do this, we have to start at the top.
Note - There's going to be a lot "I" here. This isn't because I'm being conceited or a prick, it's just because I can't speak for how you (whoever you are) develops a story. I'm not saying your method is crap, I'm saying that it's possible our two methods aren't the same. So here's my whole thought process, laid out.
I. What's the Point?
Whether it's a book or a game or set of scenarios for a game, I need to figure out what the end-goal is supposed to be. For the tournament, this was pretty clear - take 30 characters, weed them down to a smaller group, and ideally get a victor, who would "win" by not only surviving but also solving the Conspiracy (the game has a strong investigatory element) that the villains had in place. I had notes on what the Conspiracy was, and by notes I mean "Ken wrote a sentence". And I stared at it, until I figured out that it was a formula:
[Badguys] want [Ideal Situation] to happen. They're going to do/use [Event(s)] to bring it about.
Once I saw what the antagonists were going to do, it was easy to figure out what the protagonists do, which is also a formula:
[Goodguys] want to stop [Badguys] by preventing/fixing [Events] from going according to plan.
Armed now with a point, I could move to the next step, finding who the badguys were.
II. The Badguys
I knew what they were going to do, so I had to figure out what sort of person/creature/entity/being would dothose things. I put myself in the baddie's place -
Okay, I want X to happen. What does that say about me?
This differential diagnosis brought me a few tropes (I was evil, I put myself before others, I had no
compunctions about killing the innocent to forward my goal) but also a few deeper thoughts (I need to do this to survive, I must sate my needs, I'm at best a beast and a junkie masquerading as something else).
Once I had the psychology in place (not finalized, but I was at least in the ballpark), I went to the Events.
III. The Events
These are the scenarios that the players had to navigate and survive. I knew I needed 7 total (6 preliminary and 1 final), and I knew there was an over-arching plot that tied them together, so I divided them into groups.In that way, these weren't unlike chapters in a novel, something else I'm really used to creating.
I knew that each individual Event had to have a setup, a development, a climax and a resolution. And I knew that for 6 of the Events, the resolution would be "survivors advance to the next round". I worked backwards to say that the climax had to be a fight, because you need something to happen in order to say you survived, which left me the setup and development.
Setup
I had notes about what the initial setups should be. The plot was divided into chunks so that each Event would in theory give you puzzle pieces, and you'd in theory reach the end of the final event with enough pieces to make a rough sketch of the overall picture.
Each event started with getting the protagonists (the players) involved in a single story -- they had to go somewhere and do something, that by itself could have just been a whole book/event unto itself. I didn't want
them to yet realize what they did in the events was part of a larger puzzle until they were already too far in to back out. And the best way to get people to invest in a hurry is to push emotional buttons, which means
create situations where they respond maybe a little fast or hasty, learn the hard way that they can't do that a
second time, then make them cautious about each subsequent time.
It's like touching a hot stove - you only have to do it once to learn to be careful while cooking.
Each setup was a self-contained adventure that just happened to fit a larger picture because elements of that
adventure that may seem out of place locally, fit globally.
Development
So on paper, I had 6 elements that if summarized, laid out the overall plot. Like this:
THE BIG PLOT IS XYZ
* Event 1 introduces a character involved in XYZ
* Event 2 tells how big XYZ can be
* Event 3 introduces just how far the badguys are willing to go to make XYZ happen
* Event 4 introduces how XYZ is getting supported without realizing it
* Event 5 introduces what the future could turn out to be, if XYZ goes unchecked
* Event 6 explores how far XYZ is from completing Stage 1
Event 7 (the finale) will bring the players face to face with the badguys and start XYZ into motion unless the
players stop it by any means necessary.
Now, there's an assumption made here: That XYZ will go off without a hitch if no one does anything about it. I'm not the biggest fan of that, because it makes the protagonists either a) too critical, pressuring them or b) too unimportant because the plot is greater than they are. I skipped that whole assumption by making the players' actions (the protagonists) critical to the execution of XYZ - no matter what they did, they'd be helping XYZ happen, until they figured out what was wrong, and then worked to stop it.
I like stories that create character change. I like watching players see that their previously-thought-of-as-harmless action was actually one of a series of things that put this whole ball into motion. Not because I want them to be afraid to do anything in the future, but because I want them to understand that actions have consequences, and they don't always know what the results will be.
The downside with the above list of six is that they're dependent on each other. Sure you can omit Event 5 and XYZ is still a threat, but you can't really dismiss Event 1 or 4. I wrote it like that on the assumption that
people would be fighting tooth and nail for the chance to win the prize, and they'd not have other conflicts,
second thoughts or obligations.
The reality was that we had around 2 dozen players, which means we didn't have enough protagonists to run all 6 events. So, which events do we omit? Which Events can go so that the plot still makes sense and allows the players a chance to win the prize?
We ended up running Event 1, Event 2 and Event 3, patching holes in plots and taking elements from 4, 5 and 6 to make them fatter and juicier with details. My great regret is that 4 5 and 6 weren't run, because they were, in my opinion, my better writing (I hit my stride and my confidence). Hopefully, I'll have a chance in the near future to put together the whole story arc for players.
But how did each Event get built?
IV. Event/Scenario Building
I talked above about how these scenarios are chapters of a bigger book, but maybe a better description is that they're short stories within an anthology. Each Scenario has its own components:
* The players get a mission
* The mission starts off okay, but takes a turn for the worse
* The players discover this mission is part of a bigger picture (they get clues to XYZ!)
* The players have to stop the immediate threat
Key here are the clues, obviously. And to create clues, you have to look at the XYZ plot and figure out what
components make it happen. Paperwork, notes, maps, phone numbers, all the cogs of the machine. And then you scatter those cogs throughout the Scenarios. But you don't do it blindly, there needs to be a
reasonable connection as to why badguy #6 has a particular clue in her jacket pocket.
I found it helpful to make a huge table of clues and who had them and why. Most often the why was "because they can drive the truck" or "Because they handle the money", but assigning clues to characters with a reason made the clues more important, both for the sake of XYZ and for me writing the scenes and beats where the clues could be found -- no one wants to just walk into a room and see the smoking gun on the table, it's unfair to everyone.
With the clues in place, I had to go back to my initial assignment. Ideally there would be 30 people competing in this tournament, and we couldn't have 30 people around 1 table for a finale. I had to thin the herd.
V. Characters & Villains (and balancing them)
Here's where I raise my hand and say I screwed this up. It was fixable, and we took care of it when the problem arose, BUT I should have done a better job. I didn't want there to be any problems, and with that attitude and pressure, of course there were some. Even though numerous people have told me to get over it, I'm still kicking myself. With the plot divided over 6 slices, it was time to figure out who was going to participate. I made some assumptions that a lot of people hadn't played this game to the extent I have, so they likely are going to need
a nice access route to the mechanics and the game. I also needed to divide 30 people into teams so that one team could handle an event.
I could have made generic teams. I even had notes saying that in each scenario the players were one team or
another. But that...didn't feel very big and exciting and "Signature Event" the way this tournament was getting
promoted. So the characters had to be special. And players needed to feel a connection to the story and their roles in it.
So I made versions of famous movie and tv characters. The MI6 team were all James Bond actors. The IMF team was a combination of the movies and TV show. The Mossad team were all famous Jewish feminists. The point was, players would get (hopefully) a character they knew something about, and that would help bridge the gap between "I don't know what I'm doing" to "I hope I'm doing this right".
They even got little backstories. A paragraph or three describing how the felt or who on their team they felt
the meshed with. My hope was that for some people, this gave some ideas on the character, if they were
unfamiliar.
And then I went to give them stats, and blew it.
When I build characters, they're at a certain level, usually a low one, because these characters are going to
exist and persist for a long time and they'll get better over the course of many adventures. Also, they're not
facing super-terrible horrors right from the jump, so low-powering them isn't a bad thing.
It's a great strategy when you've got time on your side. It's a terrible strategy for a tournament where you
have only so many sessions and hours to accomplish a lot in. But it's fixable. One of the nice things about having the game's creator on hand is that he can knock out some mechanics in his head and we can on-the-fly make changes that will repair things.
Reparations, though, are only needed when you have really big villains. And I did. I spent time building
villains, I delighted in figuring out which creature was where....all with the goal of "What will kill players
the coolest (and if necessary, fastest)".
And pre-tournament, everything was great. And then the players showed up.
VI. The Players
Introducing the human element (be they players or readers) into any story is a risk. They might not like theplot, they might not follow the story through to its conclusion. They might tell their friends the story blows. In a game, they may see the plot, and then make a hard left turn into some strange and foreign story where
quick-thinking and iron nerves make it all seamless (when really all you want to do is put your head against the table and cry).
What do I mean, you ask?
Well let's suppose your characters are on a mission to rescue hostages on a boat. And in the course of that
rescue operation, they engage in a pretty nasty fight in the bowels of the ship. And their resolution to the
fight is to blow a hole in the side of the ship...just below the waterline, so that the hostages they're meant
to save and the clues they're supposed to find all go to Davy Jones' Locker.
Or let's suppose the character is tasked with protecting a vital non-player-character. Let's further say that
the player elects to protect that non-player-character by wooing her, and then, in order to protect her, finds
it necessary to knock her out, tie her up and eventually throw her off a balcony into a swimming pool. You know, for her protection.
Or let's say the whole plot is moving along, and the players reach what are likely the last ten minutes of play
and they...well, they collectively decide to leave. I don't mean the players walk out of the room, I mean the
characters elect to steal an NPC's car and drive away from the story but not before sealing hundreds of
innocents into a building with monsters.
When I'm writing fiction, or whenever there's a one-way conversation going on (I write it, time passes, someone reads it), the worst case scenario is that people dislike what I've written, and they move on to other things.
When that same conversation is two-way or interactive, the worst case scenario is an ever escalating mess of
responses made hastily, rather than logically. Like this:
Example
--------
GM: The creature appears out of the shadows. It's bad.
Player: I run away.
GM: (who didn't plan for this) Um...uhh...there's a second monster by the door.
Player: Then I jump out the window.
GM: (in whose mind the story is falling out the window too): You're on the sixth floor.
Player: I have a hang glider.
The end result? The player is frustrated, the GM is frustrated and the story dies on the vine.
I'm not upset that people won the tournament, they were supposed to win. People had a great time and I loved running the session I did. Am I hurt that the whole storyline wasn't told? Yes. Is that really a problem? No.
VII. What I Learned
The biggest takeway here is that while you must have an end-goal, the point of interactive storytelling is tomake the journey to that goal just as big (or bigger) then the end-result. Yes, the players were supposed to win the tournament, that was the point, but HOW they got there was not only a condition of winning but also the reason why they spent hours of a Saturday afternoon in a cold boardroom.
Follow that closely with the idea that the best element of story is emotion and the best element of interactive
storytelling is flexibility. To make players care about what they do, (and not make this just an exercise to win
a cash-prize) they have to care, even in some imaginative way that what they say these creations are doing has a consequence that affects them. And likewise, when those characters undertake plans that are way off-book, the GM has to be flexible in either going with the flow (vamping and pulling the story slowly back to plot or absolutely chucking the story and working extemporaneously) or running the risk of admitting defeat and terminating whatever good experience the collective group is having.
Last, I learned a valuable lesson in confidence. I was prepared, I may have made some mistakes, but rather than leap off building to my doom, or spend hours convinced that everyone hated me, I rolled with it. Okay yes, I got a couple glares, eye rolls and sighs. Yes, we had to figure something out on the fly. Was it the end of the world? Nope. Was I not repeatedly lauded and praised for all the hard work? Yes. And that makes me feel so much better about so many of the things I'm doing, both in and out of gaming.
A good time was had by all, and I am so thankful and grateful for the opportunity to be a part of it. In the
event that this tournament becomes a regular thing (which it can be, if you make your voices heard), I'm all
over it.
Have a great day. Later this week, I'll talk about more stuff gaming taught me.
Monday, July 9, 2012
What I Learned This Week At DexCon
This week was DexCon, the annual summer gaming convention that happens between Origins and GenCon (the two other big summer conventions). And if you've been anywhere near me lately, you likely got sucked into the tornado that was John-prepping-for-a-convention.
This year I was assisting in the running of a Signature Event, a tournament of Night's Black Agents where the winning team scored a $1,000 for surviving and discovering the conspiracy unfolding around them. I am forever grateful to the tremendous assistance and support of Ken Hite, the game's creator as well as Bill White, the third GM for their enthusiasm and patience with me -- I have no doubt I was an over-compensating buzz of frantic anxiety, and they were masterful in keeping me on track and keeping everything moving forward.
Granted, my job seemed easy - I had to create the 30 characters for participants to use, as well as develop adventures designed to both give the players clues as well as winnow down the 30 players to a final round. We were successful, and I felt a tremendous sense of relief and adrenal relaxation (I suddenly lost an invisible 60 pounds of "what if this sucks?" I had been carrying). And the whole event, which mauled my Saturday, taught me A LOT.
Combine that with likely one of my top-four workshops (which is no longer at midnight, and comes with coffee for the morning crowd) and I am deeply happy man. That also taught me a lot.
I list those things now. When I talk about "it" (whatever "it" is) just replace that word with your book/game/project/thing you're doing).
1. It doesn't have to be perfect, it has to be the best you can do, and you have to give a shit about it. When I said yes to the opportunity to co-run a tournament, and once I got past the excitement of "I'm going to play one of my all-time favorite games with one of my favorite people who happens to be the guy who wrote the game!" and I saw the amount of work I had to do, it was tough not to get immediately paralyzed.
Create 30 characters that were pitch-perfect, interesting and accessible to players as well as seven scenarios that would weed through players and characters all within a 6-or-so-hour block? Gulp. I have experience making characters, I've even thought at times I was good at it, because I'm really just filling out an excel sheet, but this....this is serious! I can't just have "my" kind of characters, I need to have Grade-A characters (kudos if you just caught the implication that I doubt myself sometimes).
And I just can't have decent or average plots, I have to have plots good enough for the guy who wrote the game will respect and enjoy and not scowl at me all the way through. I can't suck at this. (Cue anxiety, nervous stomach and panic sweats)
So, I sat down, talked myself down off that ledge and got to work.
a) I know how to do this.
b) I do this for my friends all the time.
c) I'm not working in a vacuum, I have people (like the game's creator, duh) who can help me
d) and if it all goes pear-shaped, who cares, it's a game, not nuclear disarmament talks with the Iranians)
And I did it. It was time-consuming, and it was essentially its own clinic in game design, story development and how-John-deals-with-the-spotlight, but I did it. Likely, when I tell you that I had also dropped about $90 at Staples to get pencils, erasers and folders, you'll tell me that I overdid it, but the fact remained that I put all these things together. I don't say that so that people say "Oh wow that's amazing." I say that so that I get it in my own damn head that I took on a big project and kicked its ass.
Was it perfect? Nope. Characters were under-powered, plots had holes, and my printer is low on toner, but all those things are fixable, despite my frustration and guilt that I didn't do a perfect job, what I got was teased, not yelled at for the errors. And the errors got fixed, and a good time was had by all.
2. There are few things as nerve wracking as watching someone else go through your work with an audience, especially when they're the developer of the game upon which your work is based. I'm used to people critiquing my writing. I go to meetings, I share my work with a lot of people, and they give me feedback (usually it's "keep writing this!" and "stop thinking that you're not good at it!" etc etc), so I have no problem sharing my work when my work is prose - someone reads it, they make comments, I'm used to that.
But it is wholly a different beast when what you've written is something interactive. When you watch someone at the top of the field take your work and make it come alive for an audience in a way you didn't realize possible. It wasn't just roll a few dice and say something, it was a moving, near-theater experience. It was as gaming should be - a dive into deep waters of imagination and story-telling where everyone is equally invested and equally enraptured by the tale and their contributions to it.
So I'm sitting there in the back of the room, watching Ken lead the final table through the plot. I know where the monsters are. I know where the red flags are. But what Ken did was transform them from simple encounters and bullet-points on page 4 into a story, and he painted (I mean like Van Gogh) a picture of an adventure and enemies and tension and excitement that I had some inkling of on the page...but Ken filled in the dots in a way that I don't think anyone else could. He made my words not suck. He made them awesome.
That is scary though. While the other people in the room are listening to the players gasp and laugh and cheer and panic and play, I'm listening to the plot, I'm waiting for "Okay, does this monster kill them?" and "What about the clue?" That tension goes far beyond I-hope-there's-a-winner and turns into oh-god-I-hope-this-doesn't-suck-for-people. But...we made it. Hooray!
3. The biggest interference in a plot are the characters. The plot for the tournament, I felt, was one of the cleanest and jaw-dropping-est I-can't-believe-that's-a-thing plots I've ever worked on. It was so not a "go to Place A, retrieve item B, fight enemy C" affairs, but it rather intricately wove about 2 dozen clues together so that people could follow along.
Of course that somewhat assumes they will follow along. When one character takes the lady he's supposed to protect and seduces her, then knocks her unconscious and throws her out a window into a pool (so the badguys can't get her), that's both one hell of a mixed message as well as something I wouldn't think to do.
Likewise when characters are marshaling their forces and say "We need a flamethrower", that's not really something you can plan for. And no, you cannot plan for everything. The characters will surprise you when you leave them open-ended and provide fertilizer for the seed beds of imagination. (No, this isn't the time to get into that discussion about whether you or not you "let the characters dictate the story as you write it", this isn't the place for that.)
I'm not saying that people are going to sabotage the plot, but you just have to roll with the punches when characters decide to make a hard-left out of the story and take it in a new direction. Granted this weekend we had neither time nor energy to vamp for 3 hours to get them back on track, so there was a huge margin of flexing, but as the developer of content, much like Moff Tarkin, you can't hold too tightly to your plans, else things slip through your fingers. And I guess your British accent will come and go. Or something.
4. You need to take care of yourself. So I worked on this tournament and then decided that a six-hour marathon game wasn't enough, that I would pull myself to my feet and play in another game that went from midnight until about 2am or so. Because that's the healthiest response I could make, right? So by the time I fell asleep it was around 3:30 and I had to be up at 8:30 and ready to give a workshop at 10.
Also, if you're scoring along at home, I am not 22 with a super metabolism and incredibly springy immune system. Oh, and I've fractured my ankle recently, depending on which medical authority you talk to (sprain, fracture, break, microfracture, these terms are but commas in medical sentences), so I'm gimping along on one leg and doing my best to pop Advil here and there and rest whenever possible. So what's more restful than gaming for 12 hours straight?
On Sunday I had a GREAT, SUPER AMAZING WORKSHOP with a fantastic and detailed discussion of writing - covering discipline and habits and goal-setting and related ideas. I also answered a ton of questions (there were some wonderful questions this time), but I was so tired, I wanted to be more enthusiastic and answer more questions and get more into how to individually help people....but I just ran out of gas. I was tired and worn down and needed to rest.
It should be mentioned that this whole weekend it was hot. Like crazy living-in-a-furnace hot. Like 89 degrees at 2am hot. Hydration was the order of the day, and when I was hydrated, I felt great, I was awake and my foot didn't hurt. When I was way behind in my waterload, I was sluggish, tired and a little babbling.
Those times when I stretched out in a chair, put my leg up and drank water? Incredibly restorative. I didn't feel like I needed to be go-go-go all the time, I was better for not pressuring myself to do more.
So, summary time:
Take good care of yourself, and it makes stressful high-energy times worth it.
You're going to end up stressing yourself out trying to be perfect, you'll be much better off trusting yourself to do the best job possible.
More than you realize, there are very likely a lot more people who support you and actually like you, rather than who just tolerate your presence.
Happy writing. Later this week, I'll do a post about how my writing has changed because of this experience.
This year I was assisting in the running of a Signature Event, a tournament of Night's Black Agents where the winning team scored a $1,000 for surviving and discovering the conspiracy unfolding around them. I am forever grateful to the tremendous assistance and support of Ken Hite, the game's creator as well as Bill White, the third GM for their enthusiasm and patience with me -- I have no doubt I was an over-compensating buzz of frantic anxiety, and they were masterful in keeping me on track and keeping everything moving forward.
Granted, my job seemed easy - I had to create the 30 characters for participants to use, as well as develop adventures designed to both give the players clues as well as winnow down the 30 players to a final round. We were successful, and I felt a tremendous sense of relief and adrenal relaxation (I suddenly lost an invisible 60 pounds of "what if this sucks?" I had been carrying). And the whole event, which mauled my Saturday, taught me A LOT.
Combine that with likely one of my top-four workshops (which is no longer at midnight, and comes with coffee for the morning crowd) and I am deeply happy man. That also taught me a lot.
I list those things now. When I talk about "it" (whatever "it" is) just replace that word with your book/game/project/thing you're doing).
1. It doesn't have to be perfect, it has to be the best you can do, and you have to give a shit about it. When I said yes to the opportunity to co-run a tournament, and once I got past the excitement of "I'm going to play one of my all-time favorite games with one of my favorite people who happens to be the guy who wrote the game!" and I saw the amount of work I had to do, it was tough not to get immediately paralyzed.
Create 30 characters that were pitch-perfect, interesting and accessible to players as well as seven scenarios that would weed through players and characters all within a 6-or-so-hour block? Gulp. I have experience making characters, I've even thought at times I was good at it, because I'm really just filling out an excel sheet, but this....this is serious! I can't just have "my" kind of characters, I need to have Grade-A characters (kudos if you just caught the implication that I doubt myself sometimes).
And I just can't have decent or average plots, I have to have plots good enough for the guy who wrote the game will respect and enjoy and not scowl at me all the way through. I can't suck at this. (Cue anxiety, nervous stomach and panic sweats)
So, I sat down, talked myself down off that ledge and got to work.
a) I know how to do this.
b) I do this for my friends all the time.
c) I'm not working in a vacuum, I have people (like the game's creator, duh) who can help me
d) and if it all goes pear-shaped, who cares, it's a game, not nuclear disarmament talks with the Iranians)
And I did it. It was time-consuming, and it was essentially its own clinic in game design, story development and how-John-deals-with-the-spotlight, but I did it. Likely, when I tell you that I had also dropped about $90 at Staples to get pencils, erasers and folders, you'll tell me that I overdid it, but the fact remained that I put all these things together. I don't say that so that people say "Oh wow that's amazing." I say that so that I get it in my own damn head that I took on a big project and kicked its ass.
Was it perfect? Nope. Characters were under-powered, plots had holes, and my printer is low on toner, but all those things are fixable, despite my frustration and guilt that I didn't do a perfect job, what I got was teased, not yelled at for the errors. And the errors got fixed, and a good time was had by all.
2. There are few things as nerve wracking as watching someone else go through your work with an audience, especially when they're the developer of the game upon which your work is based. I'm used to people critiquing my writing. I go to meetings, I share my work with a lot of people, and they give me feedback (usually it's "keep writing this!" and "stop thinking that you're not good at it!" etc etc), so I have no problem sharing my work when my work is prose - someone reads it, they make comments, I'm used to that.
But it is wholly a different beast when what you've written is something interactive. When you watch someone at the top of the field take your work and make it come alive for an audience in a way you didn't realize possible. It wasn't just roll a few dice and say something, it was a moving, near-theater experience. It was as gaming should be - a dive into deep waters of imagination and story-telling where everyone is equally invested and equally enraptured by the tale and their contributions to it.
So I'm sitting there in the back of the room, watching Ken lead the final table through the plot. I know where the monsters are. I know where the red flags are. But what Ken did was transform them from simple encounters and bullet-points on page 4 into a story, and he painted (I mean like Van Gogh) a picture of an adventure and enemies and tension and excitement that I had some inkling of on the page...but Ken filled in the dots in a way that I don't think anyone else could. He made my words not suck. He made them awesome.
That is scary though. While the other people in the room are listening to the players gasp and laugh and cheer and panic and play, I'm listening to the plot, I'm waiting for "Okay, does this monster kill them?" and "What about the clue?" That tension goes far beyond I-hope-there's-a-winner and turns into oh-god-I-hope-this-doesn't-suck-for-people. But...we made it. Hooray!
3. The biggest interference in a plot are the characters. The plot for the tournament, I felt, was one of the cleanest and jaw-dropping-est I-can't-believe-that's-a-thing plots I've ever worked on. It was so not a "go to Place A, retrieve item B, fight enemy C" affairs, but it rather intricately wove about 2 dozen clues together so that people could follow along.
Of course that somewhat assumes they will follow along. When one character takes the lady he's supposed to protect and seduces her, then knocks her unconscious and throws her out a window into a pool (so the badguys can't get her), that's both one hell of a mixed message as well as something I wouldn't think to do.
Likewise when characters are marshaling their forces and say "We need a flamethrower", that's not really something you can plan for. And no, you cannot plan for everything. The characters will surprise you when you leave them open-ended and provide fertilizer for the seed beds of imagination. (No, this isn't the time to get into that discussion about whether you or not you "let the characters dictate the story as you write it", this isn't the place for that.)
I'm not saying that people are going to sabotage the plot, but you just have to roll with the punches when characters decide to make a hard-left out of the story and take it in a new direction. Granted this weekend we had neither time nor energy to vamp for 3 hours to get them back on track, so there was a huge margin of flexing, but as the developer of content, much like Moff Tarkin, you can't hold too tightly to your plans, else things slip through your fingers. And I guess your British accent will come and go. Or something.
4. You need to take care of yourself. So I worked on this tournament and then decided that a six-hour marathon game wasn't enough, that I would pull myself to my feet and play in another game that went from midnight until about 2am or so. Because that's the healthiest response I could make, right? So by the time I fell asleep it was around 3:30 and I had to be up at 8:30 and ready to give a workshop at 10.
Also, if you're scoring along at home, I am not 22 with a super metabolism and incredibly springy immune system. Oh, and I've fractured my ankle recently, depending on which medical authority you talk to (sprain, fracture, break, microfracture, these terms are but commas in medical sentences), so I'm gimping along on one leg and doing my best to pop Advil here and there and rest whenever possible. So what's more restful than gaming for 12 hours straight?
On Sunday I had a GREAT, SUPER AMAZING WORKSHOP with a fantastic and detailed discussion of writing - covering discipline and habits and goal-setting and related ideas. I also answered a ton of questions (there were some wonderful questions this time), but I was so tired, I wanted to be more enthusiastic and answer more questions and get more into how to individually help people....but I just ran out of gas. I was tired and worn down and needed to rest.
It should be mentioned that this whole weekend it was hot. Like crazy living-in-a-furnace hot. Like 89 degrees at 2am hot. Hydration was the order of the day, and when I was hydrated, I felt great, I was awake and my foot didn't hurt. When I was way behind in my waterload, I was sluggish, tired and a little babbling.
Those times when I stretched out in a chair, put my leg up and drank water? Incredibly restorative. I didn't feel like I needed to be go-go-go all the time, I was better for not pressuring myself to do more.
So, summary time:
Take good care of yourself, and it makes stressful high-energy times worth it.
You're going to end up stressing yourself out trying to be perfect, you'll be much better off trusting yourself to do the best job possible.
More than you realize, there are very likely a lot more people who support you and actually like you, rather than who just tolerate your presence.
Happy writing. Later this week, I'll do a post about how my writing has changed because of this experience.
Friday, April 27, 2012
Publishing & What's Important
This post may not make you very comfortable. It may not make you happy. But since this blog is designed to accomplish exactly neither of those things, I'm going to use this space to talk about my thoughts and feelings about publishing. I'm going to try and not quote numbers or limit myself to specific citations, I want this to be broad view not because I don't know the particulars but rather I believe that it is in the particulars where all the fighting happens, where people see a stat or get a quote and blow things way the hell out of proportion.
So this is just me, John, talking to you, the writer/creator/artist/producer/game developer/whatever you call yourself. This is not my axe to grind or my "converting you to one side or the other" because, as you'll see, I don't care what side you're on, so long as you're creating for the best/right reasons. Before we go any further, we should talk about those reasons.
Why are you creating the thing you are? Doesn't matter what it is, so long as it's lawful, doesn't harm kids or sap my life force out of my body, I'm not really going to oppose you doing it. I'm going to be honest with you though, there are some reasons that are better than others.
Creating art should not be done so that you be taken seriously. Creating art is not going to repair the relationships you've screwed up by being obnoxious, immature, unprepared, crabby, bitchy, catty, superficial, dull, uncaring, mean or intoxicated. I'm not talking shit about art therapy, but that's therapy designed for the patient - the random person who hates you for what you did isn't going to suddenly forgive you because you drew a sunflower. Sorry, it might be the best sunflower this side of Van Gogh, but that person has made a decision to hate you and its an apology, not a canvas that's going to fix that bridge.
Creating art also shouldn't be for financial gain. Yes, sure, you can make a living producing and selling your work. And yes, sometimes, that living is going to be comfortable. Other times though, you're going to look at the Groupon emails in your inbox and say, "Not this week, I gotta pay my electric bill." I'm not saying you shouldn't make money off your art, it's your art and you can do what you want with it, but I'm saying that if you're just churning out material so that your bank account swells, or so that your spouse can "live in a style they're accustomed to" its very likely that what you're selling is your soul and what you're buying is empty space in a destructive relationship (believe me, I've been there.)
Creating art also isn't a badge of superiority. Way back in caveman days, when your ancestor cracked some quadraped in the mush with a rock, they could hold up the pelt or the skull and that was superiority, exclaiming to the heavens and the rest of the tribe, I did this, I am better than you. But there's also a purpose there - dead quadraped equals dinner, so providing for the tribe is better than mooching off Thog's rock prowess. And the guy who told the first novel on a cave wall, he wasn't doing it for an Amazon ranking, or for First Rights, he was doing it so that the tribe could pass on a story and learn from their experiences. Again, a purpose, not just a mark of I'm-better-than-you.
So why do it? Because if you don't, if you don't get the story out, your head will melt. If other people don't sit down and experience what you're creating, then some part of you, some part however "flawed" people may term it or think it, goes unsatisfied. Creating scratches some deep itch and fills a hole that no amount of dead quadraped trophies or fancy purchases can top.
But the downside to creating is that you create in dynamic times, which I guess is the John-version of that Chinese proverb. And change now isn't the enemy, it's not the thing keeping you from creating (if you think it is, then you're just afraid and you're letting the fear stop you from doing what you love**)
**Note: If you are afraid, ask yourself, if this wasn't about creating....if this was about getting laid or playing a game or eating your favorite meal or making yourself happy, would you let yourself be stopped?
Change happens. The car replaced the horse. The mp3 replaced the phonograph. The smartphone replaced the old Bakelite desk monstrosity. Your ability to adapt and work with (not against) that change, even sometimes acting in favor of change is what's going to make your end goal all the easier.
What end goal? Well that's up to you. I cannot tell you your end goal, nor can any author, publisher, owner, bazillionaire, celebrity or religious figure. Like He-Man, you have the power to determine your end goals, and you should. And they should be HUGE because that's how you get better. Yeah, that makes them difficult to accomplish, but nothing worthwhile is easy.
My end goal is to tell stories and get those stories into the hands of people who pay to read them. Notice that this particular goal doesn't claim sole ownership of the stories. Yes, I have my own stories to tell, but while I'm telling those, I can help other people tell theirs. I want all kinds of stories to be available, so long as they're told with the best ability to be told and they're told to people who give a damn about sharing them.
When it comes to telling stories, there are loads of media options and there are loads of ways to distribute that media. In fact, understanding the flow and distribution of your media is critical, but that's something I'll probably end up writing in another post. For now, let's just agree that there are lots of ways to skin the cat called "publishing".
There was a time, yes, when you had ONE road to get published. You wrote/typed your manuscript, you dumped it into an envelope and mailed it off to some "big city" office where someone you didn't know and didn't communicate with made some sort of gross and broad determination based on criteria and metrics you knew nothing about that somehow defined whether or not your work was "good enough" to be read by the masses. And they took you on as a client and acted as a middleman to help sell your manuscript to other "big city" offices that you definitely didn't communicate with because it was akin to mortals chatting up Olympus, and your manuscript, the little pages that could, went so far out of your hands and someone else gave you approval and validation that your hard work was worth it.
That, if you're paying attention, is traditional publishing. You write something, go shop it around and hunt for an agent and then the agent goes and finds a publisher. It's one route to getting your book into the hands of readers. It is no longer the only route.
It's also not the "best" route. There isn't a "best" route. If the route you take achieves the same end result, then who's going to bitch about how you did it? And okay, let's say you find some people who will bitch about the method - do you really want to associate yourself with those people?
Things have changed. You have options now, and it has to do with how much work you want to assert in getting your art into other people's hands. Now I'm not trying to imply you're lazy or anything, if you want to go the traditional route, but please please remember:
i. No method is "better" than any other.
ii. No method is "right".
iii. Publication isn't validation, it's a transaction, it's something you've done in your step towards your end goal.
iv. Publication isn't legitimacy.
Here's my note about legitimacy, which I talked about when I got interviewed on Jennisodes -- There was a convention of game designers and creators about 5 minutes from my house. These were people whose products I owned, people I admired and people I thought I'd never be "good enough" to associate with on any level beyond "I buy your stuff". And I got there early, and sat in the lobby, and watched people (some I knew, some I didn't) all congregate and greet each other. They all radiated this sense of belonging, like it was a big fraternity/society, practically a family, and this was just what they did. And here's me, the overweight guy who feels like he's best suited to live under a bridge sometimes and who often prefers the company of books and games to humans, sitting in the lobby, feeling very much like the kid picked last in gym class. And as I sat there, I said to myself, "I could leave. I mean, I paid like $50 bucks or something for this event, and I have a workshop to do, but it's at midnight and I can just do it and bail or whatever." I didn't feel like I belonged, is what I'm saying. I didn't feel legit. But over that weekend, I started talking to people. I figured if they were going to laugh me away, at least it was a short walk back to the house and I could spend the weekend playing Xbox on the couch. They, to date, haven't laughed me away. In fact, they keep handing me work and keep asking for my help and my opinion and they invite me to barbecues and other states and to meetings with people. So I don't know what I did, but to this day I keep taking steps towards my goal -- tell stories, help other people get their stories told.
Legitimacy, I have discovered thus far, comes from me knowing that I'm capable to do a really great job on the projects I'm lucky enough to be a part of. I'll say that a different way - the fact that I'm attached to this project or that project or this company or this developer is not proof that I'm legitimate -- the fact that every day I get to wake up and do all the things that make me absolutely ridiculously happy are what make me legitimate. Because I'm the only arbiter of how legit I am. Not my family. Not the readers. Not the fanbase who will buy what I'm working on. Not whoever I date or who I dated. Just me.
So with all these methods and ways to tell your story, I say, go for it. Make that podcast, read from steno pads at open mics, write blogs, make videos -- go wild.
The only "bad" option is the one where you don't go after your dreams.
Let's summarize:
1. Go after your dreams. This will not be an easy pursuit (if it is, dream bigger), but the things that truly matter are not easily obtained.
2. Don't let anything or anyone external dictate the validation or the reason for why you do whatever you do.
3. You are the sole judge of your "legitimacy", not the method you take to accomplishment, and not the reception you get from people who may not yet fully enjoy/understand/accept what it is you're doing.
4. Once you set a goal, go after it. If you're able to put it down because it doesn't excite or interest you, it's not a goal. It's just something you like doing.
5. Don't let anything get in the way of #4.
6. What's "best" for you is the route that allows you to meet or exceed your goal/dreams and you'll know you're on the right path because it'll never feel like you're doing work and you'll always want to do it instead of distracting yourself from it.
Have a great weekend, happy writing.
So this is just me, John, talking to you, the writer/creator/artist/producer/game developer/whatever you call yourself. This is not my axe to grind or my "converting you to one side or the other" because, as you'll see, I don't care what side you're on, so long as you're creating for the best/right reasons. Before we go any further, we should talk about those reasons.
Why are you creating the thing you are? Doesn't matter what it is, so long as it's lawful, doesn't harm kids or sap my life force out of my body, I'm not really going to oppose you doing it. I'm going to be honest with you though, there are some reasons that are better than others.
Creating art should not be done so that you be taken seriously. Creating art is not going to repair the relationships you've screwed up by being obnoxious, immature, unprepared, crabby, bitchy, catty, superficial, dull, uncaring, mean or intoxicated. I'm not talking shit about art therapy, but that's therapy designed for the patient - the random person who hates you for what you did isn't going to suddenly forgive you because you drew a sunflower. Sorry, it might be the best sunflower this side of Van Gogh, but that person has made a decision to hate you and its an apology, not a canvas that's going to fix that bridge.
Creating art also shouldn't be for financial gain. Yes, sure, you can make a living producing and selling your work. And yes, sometimes, that living is going to be comfortable. Other times though, you're going to look at the Groupon emails in your inbox and say, "Not this week, I gotta pay my electric bill." I'm not saying you shouldn't make money off your art, it's your art and you can do what you want with it, but I'm saying that if you're just churning out material so that your bank account swells, or so that your spouse can "live in a style they're accustomed to" its very likely that what you're selling is your soul and what you're buying is empty space in a destructive relationship (believe me, I've been there.)
Creating art also isn't a badge of superiority. Way back in caveman days, when your ancestor cracked some quadraped in the mush with a rock, they could hold up the pelt or the skull and that was superiority, exclaiming to the heavens and the rest of the tribe, I did this, I am better than you. But there's also a purpose there - dead quadraped equals dinner, so providing for the tribe is better than mooching off Thog's rock prowess. And the guy who told the first novel on a cave wall, he wasn't doing it for an Amazon ranking, or for First Rights, he was doing it so that the tribe could pass on a story and learn from their experiences. Again, a purpose, not just a mark of I'm-better-than-you.
So why do it? Because if you don't, if you don't get the story out, your head will melt. If other people don't sit down and experience what you're creating, then some part of you, some part however "flawed" people may term it or think it, goes unsatisfied. Creating scratches some deep itch and fills a hole that no amount of dead quadraped trophies or fancy purchases can top.
But the downside to creating is that you create in dynamic times, which I guess is the John-version of that Chinese proverb. And change now isn't the enemy, it's not the thing keeping you from creating (if you think it is, then you're just afraid and you're letting the fear stop you from doing what you love**)
**Note: If you are afraid, ask yourself, if this wasn't about creating....if this was about getting laid or playing a game or eating your favorite meal or making yourself happy, would you let yourself be stopped?
Change happens. The car replaced the horse. The mp3 replaced the phonograph. The smartphone replaced the old Bakelite desk monstrosity. Your ability to adapt and work with (not against) that change, even sometimes acting in favor of change is what's going to make your end goal all the easier.
What end goal? Well that's up to you. I cannot tell you your end goal, nor can any author, publisher, owner, bazillionaire, celebrity or religious figure. Like He-Man, you have the power to determine your end goals, and you should. And they should be HUGE because that's how you get better. Yeah, that makes them difficult to accomplish, but nothing worthwhile is easy.
My end goal is to tell stories and get those stories into the hands of people who pay to read them. Notice that this particular goal doesn't claim sole ownership of the stories. Yes, I have my own stories to tell, but while I'm telling those, I can help other people tell theirs. I want all kinds of stories to be available, so long as they're told with the best ability to be told and they're told to people who give a damn about sharing them.
When it comes to telling stories, there are loads of media options and there are loads of ways to distribute that media. In fact, understanding the flow and distribution of your media is critical, but that's something I'll probably end up writing in another post. For now, let's just agree that there are lots of ways to skin the cat called "publishing".
There was a time, yes, when you had ONE road to get published. You wrote/typed your manuscript, you dumped it into an envelope and mailed it off to some "big city" office where someone you didn't know and didn't communicate with made some sort of gross and broad determination based on criteria and metrics you knew nothing about that somehow defined whether or not your work was "good enough" to be read by the masses. And they took you on as a client and acted as a middleman to help sell your manuscript to other "big city" offices that you definitely didn't communicate with because it was akin to mortals chatting up Olympus, and your manuscript, the little pages that could, went so far out of your hands and someone else gave you approval and validation that your hard work was worth it.
That, if you're paying attention, is traditional publishing. You write something, go shop it around and hunt for an agent and then the agent goes and finds a publisher. It's one route to getting your book into the hands of readers. It is no longer the only route.
It's also not the "best" route. There isn't a "best" route. If the route you take achieves the same end result, then who's going to bitch about how you did it? And okay, let's say you find some people who will bitch about the method - do you really want to associate yourself with those people?
Things have changed. You have options now, and it has to do with how much work you want to assert in getting your art into other people's hands. Now I'm not trying to imply you're lazy or anything, if you want to go the traditional route, but please please remember:
i. No method is "better" than any other.
ii. No method is "right".
iii. Publication isn't validation, it's a transaction, it's something you've done in your step towards your end goal.
iv. Publication isn't legitimacy.
Here's my note about legitimacy, which I talked about when I got interviewed on Jennisodes -- There was a convention of game designers and creators about 5 minutes from my house. These were people whose products I owned, people I admired and people I thought I'd never be "good enough" to associate with on any level beyond "I buy your stuff". And I got there early, and sat in the lobby, and watched people (some I knew, some I didn't) all congregate and greet each other. They all radiated this sense of belonging, like it was a big fraternity/society, practically a family, and this was just what they did. And here's me, the overweight guy who feels like he's best suited to live under a bridge sometimes and who often prefers the company of books and games to humans, sitting in the lobby, feeling very much like the kid picked last in gym class. And as I sat there, I said to myself, "I could leave. I mean, I paid like $50 bucks or something for this event, and I have a workshop to do, but it's at midnight and I can just do it and bail or whatever." I didn't feel like I belonged, is what I'm saying. I didn't feel legit. But over that weekend, I started talking to people. I figured if they were going to laugh me away, at least it was a short walk back to the house and I could spend the weekend playing Xbox on the couch. They, to date, haven't laughed me away. In fact, they keep handing me work and keep asking for my help and my opinion and they invite me to barbecues and other states and to meetings with people. So I don't know what I did, but to this day I keep taking steps towards my goal -- tell stories, help other people get their stories told.
Legitimacy, I have discovered thus far, comes from me knowing that I'm capable to do a really great job on the projects I'm lucky enough to be a part of. I'll say that a different way - the fact that I'm attached to this project or that project or this company or this developer is not proof that I'm legitimate -- the fact that every day I get to wake up and do all the things that make me absolutely ridiculously happy are what make me legitimate. Because I'm the only arbiter of how legit I am. Not my family. Not the readers. Not the fanbase who will buy what I'm working on. Not whoever I date or who I dated. Just me.
So with all these methods and ways to tell your story, I say, go for it. Make that podcast, read from steno pads at open mics, write blogs, make videos -- go wild.
The only "bad" option is the one where you don't go after your dreams.
Let's summarize:
1. Go after your dreams. This will not be an easy pursuit (if it is, dream bigger), but the things that truly matter are not easily obtained.
2. Don't let anything or anyone external dictate the validation or the reason for why you do whatever you do.
3. You are the sole judge of your "legitimacy", not the method you take to accomplishment, and not the reception you get from people who may not yet fully enjoy/understand/accept what it is you're doing.
4. Once you set a goal, go after it. If you're able to put it down because it doesn't excite or interest you, it's not a goal. It's just something you like doing.
5. Don't let anything get in the way of #4.
6. What's "best" for you is the route that allows you to meet or exceed your goal/dreams and you'll know you're on the right path because it'll never feel like you're doing work and you'll always want to do it instead of distracting yourself from it.
Have a great weekend, happy writing.
Tuesday, April 24, 2012
The Super-Protagonist
I meant to write this post weeks earlier, when I first saw The Hunger Games. While this is not a movie review, I have two points to make, the second being the topic I want to discuss today.
I. Shaky cam does not equal action or intensity. Now maybe this is a sign that I'm getting older, or proof that I spent too many afternoons too close to speakers cranked up too high and it screwed with my inner ear, but movies lately make me dizzy. When did people take every opportunity to jiggle, wobble and rattle the camera around during even the most benign scenes to give the audience a sense of "hey something's going on and you should pay attention!" The problem is, when the camera's having a seizure, it's hard to pay attention.
Maybe it's those damn kids, and their attention spans being smashed down to fractions of a second, maybe it's because we all secretly enjoy a good jostle now and then, I have no idea....but I look at a lot of older action films (even stuff from 5 years ago) and the camera doesn't look like it's being held by a monkey going through meth withdrawal.
It's hard to convey intensity and "grr" when the camera bobs drunkenly along. If the action is supposed to rivet our eyes, why not lock in on it? If we're to invest in the anguish of a character, why not get us in a tight close-up?
And while that aggravates me, it's not why I started writing this post.
II. The Super-Protagonist is not as compelling as you think. What's a Super-Protagonist? That's a protagonist that isn't challenged by the situation they're in, but they say they are, and you sort of have to take their word for it.
Wait, John, are you saying Katniss Everdeen isn't challenged by the situation she's in? In the book, she totally says she is. And in the movie, it totally looks like she is.
If I say I have trouble opening a soda, but you see me drinking a soda, how much trouble did I really experience? You took my word for it. I told you rather than showed you that I had a problem.
Yes, it's the old show-versus-tell problem again, this time in a new minty flavor. Let's break this down.
What defines a Super-Protagonist?
Main characters are supposed to experience trouble and difficulty along their path through the plot. It's supposed to be a challenge to them, to inspire/force/require them to change states from however they were at the beginning of the story to however they're meant to be at the end. A Super-Protagonist coasts through the challenge, sure they get a scrape or a bruise here or there to prove their humanity or mortality or their toughness, but in the overall scheme of things, it's a scrape versus being beaten and bedraggled and really limping toward the finish line.
And that's Katniss?
Totally.
But does that mean you expect or want all characters to just barely scrape by?
No. I don't want all characters to just barely scrape by. I'm not asking for the global difficulty level of books to get jacked up to 'Hardcore' or 'Insane' mode, I'm just asking that the challenges be modulated for the character. Big, strong, smart, capable character? Then break out the big, powerful, brilliant, creative problems.
But...Katniss is a YA heroine and a model for girls, etc etc? Is this a sexist thing?
This has NOTHING to do with the gender of the character or the range of the readability of the book or the genre or anything like that. This has to do with the core ends of storytelling, and the ability of an author to imperil their characters appropriately, whoever they might be.
So the idea that Katniss has to leave her home, kill others and survive isn't dangerous?
Um, no. It's not.
Wha?
Well you see, Katniss is a hunter (or as I identified her, a 1st-level Ranger). So outdoor survival isn't a new skill for her. And it's not that she's set up to be a killer, she's far more interested in self-preservation than in an active killing spree (besides, that's for the badguys to do to prove that they're bad, because, like, murder is totes bad), so she's not really out of her element.
But she sacrifices herself to save her sister....
It's only sacrifice if she dies. Else she risks herself, and as I just said, sticking her in the woods, where she's far more comfortable than when she's ever anywhere else (this is really clubbed over our head in the movie), that's not a risk. It's sort of like asking me to risk myself by going and sitting in my house with a stack of books, my Xbox and an internet connection.
But it's noble.....
No it's not. She's a great character, she's driven, talented, capable and powerful, but we can't see the full breadth of her potential because she's not out of her natural element. She's not challenged by the environment or the situation once the Game starts...her challenge came before she reached the woods, when she was back in the City and had to deal with the Game set up. But the book wasn't about Katniss-in-the-City, this was about Katniss-being-Katniss, doing-Katniss-things-that-just-happen-to-be-the-things-she's-good-at-already. Ho hum.
So how is she Super, exactly?
Okay I'll spell it out:
i. Her "struggle" occurs in her native environment.
ii. It's repeatedly made clear that she'll have access to her preferred weapon/tool.
iii. It's repeatedly said by other characters that she has a good/great/the best chance of surviving.
iv. Her knowledge (something unknown to other people, but something she acquired being herself) of berries sets up the conclusion. This wasn't knowledge she learned during THIS struggle, this was knowledge she came in with.
v. Even when she is out of her element, she's put into situations where she is clearly superior to others (she gets the Penthouse, she receives the most oohs and ahhs from the audience while interviewed, she makes the most striking impression).
vi. She says rather emphatically "she's not scared", when fear would be a natural reaction to oh-now-I-have-to-kill-23-teenagers-on-tv-and-not-die-trying.
But how is that a bad thing? I liked the series!
It's not a "bad" thing. The book/thought/movie police aren't going to come to your house and take away your ability to enjoy the experience, I'm just saying that writers need to be careful not to let themselves get drunk on the brew of their own protagonists.
Are you talking about character balance?
Partially, yes. But it goes deeper than that. This isn't just about making sure there's a flaw to counteract every positive you grant the character.
It's okay, I've given my super-smart, strong, attractive lead character a horrific mental disorder and/or drug addiction! Problem solved, right?
No....that's sort of exactly the problem.
Imagine a scale from -10 to +10. The character starts at 0, the center, and when you list the positive abilities or attributes, you move the character positively up the scale.
And every time you give your character a flaw or a drawback or a hindrance or penalize them in some way, you slide that character back negatively so the overall effect is a dramatically lower state -
Which has the added complication of meaning you have to overcome that negative state when the story climaxes to prove the character positive overall
Now the tendency here is say, 'Oh but my character is so awesome, she's no longer believable, so I'll offset these mega bonuses with a super huge negative!' So that your sporty, independent, intelligent, outspoken, attractive female star now has cooties, agoraphobia and....really bad cramps or something.
Look: You don't have to swing the pendulum that far back to offset the positives. You don't need to -7 the character just to make us like them. We'll like the character for the SUM of the positives and negatives, but that means you have to show us both sides and trust us to make our own decisions.
Wait, what do I have to do?
You (the author) have to trust us (the readers) to make up our own minds about your character(s) after you present us the character(s).
But what if I want to hold something back from the reader for later?
If that "something" is skill or knowledge or something, be careful, it may come across as convenient (i.e. Your character knows just the right fact about a shoe print). If that "something is backstory, be careful, because it may change the way some readers respond to the character. (i.e. We finally learn the reason Character Bro is a douchebag, and it's different than our opinions, therefore we will make hyperbolic statements on the interwebs and rage at you!!)
I'm not saying that every story needs to spell out EVERY facet of a character for the reader. You, author, can pick and choose what you want to say and how you want to say it, but I'm cautioning you that the idea of "sum to date" (what the reader knows at whatever their relative "present" moment is) is how they judge the character - and it can be unfair to ask them to wait for stories down the road to hold off on passing judgement, especially if you spend a lot of the story cementing an idea that this character is pretty much an unstoppable force in your created universe.
But, I want the readers to love this character!
Yes, we all want that. We all want readers to love our characters, but we'll love them all the more when we see them pushed to their limits, overcome obstacles we didn't know they could and take on bigger odds to make themselves more heroic.
If you play it safe with your character, you're doing us a disservice as readers (we won't get to know the character fully) and you're doing a disservice to yourself (you're not testing yourself as best you can as a writer). If you think your character is so original and so "out of the box", ask yourself how big the box is. And how much of that box does the reader know about at any given time.
But I'm scared. What if I suck? Or fail or get it wrong?
That's sort of what makes writing hard, but worthwhile. If you do it everyday, if you commit to it, you'll get better at it. That's about the best I can tell you without getting all ranty or raining on your parade.
What can I learn from Katniss as a character?
Well, a lot, if you like physically strong and capable female protagonists with a skillset and mindset to overcome obstacles. Slightly less if you want to use her for an intelligence study (there are characters in other books admittedly older, more experienced and smarter), and slightly less than that if you want to use her for an emotional study (there are characters who experience and demonstrate a wider swath of emotions more intensely and more visibly and more acutely). But you'll get far more if you learn the pitfalls.
I. Risk includes taking the character out of their comfort zone. Like all the way out. Nero Wolfe left the brownstone (under protest, but he did); Sherlock Holmes (especially in the modern version) struggled more with people than casework; Captain America was a paragon in the 1940s, but lost in a sea of individualism in the modern era.
II. Your character does not need to be nearly flawless to be liked. Katniss has "a voice birds go silent to hear" and "a beauty enhanced by what's inside". Those are pretty high watermarks for a character. You don't need to be the best ever just to be liked (it comes off desperate and fearful on the part of the author when you've made characters that are too perfect).
III. Your character does not need to be mega-super-flawed to be realistic. You don't need to take that super skilled character and give them crippling Asperger's. Nor do you need to make them the angstiest-girl-in-high-school-like-OMG-why-won't-Edward-like-notice-me. Remember the number line, you don't need the character to 'zero' out. You need the character just end up positive if you want a positive ending, or negative if you want a negative ending.
IV. When in doubt, SHOW us the situation and SHOW us the character's responses and reactions, rather than tell us what they're thinking. Let the reader draw their own conclusions (which you can't control anyway), and stop dictating to us what 'we're supposed to think/feel' even if you're worried about us 'getting it right'. Paint for us the picture, and we'll 'get it', but yes, that means you (author) have to do some work and demonstrate your skill and your craft. Sorry, them's the tradeoff.
Anything else?
Yeah, when you make the movie version of your book, stop shaking the damned camera.
I. Shaky cam does not equal action or intensity. Now maybe this is a sign that I'm getting older, or proof that I spent too many afternoons too close to speakers cranked up too high and it screwed with my inner ear, but movies lately make me dizzy. When did people take every opportunity to jiggle, wobble and rattle the camera around during even the most benign scenes to give the audience a sense of "hey something's going on and you should pay attention!" The problem is, when the camera's having a seizure, it's hard to pay attention.
Maybe it's those damn kids, and their attention spans being smashed down to fractions of a second, maybe it's because we all secretly enjoy a good jostle now and then, I have no idea....but I look at a lot of older action films (even stuff from 5 years ago) and the camera doesn't look like it's being held by a monkey going through meth withdrawal.
It's hard to convey intensity and "grr" when the camera bobs drunkenly along. If the action is supposed to rivet our eyes, why not lock in on it? If we're to invest in the anguish of a character, why not get us in a tight close-up?
And while that aggravates me, it's not why I started writing this post.
II. The Super-Protagonist is not as compelling as you think. What's a Super-Protagonist? That's a protagonist that isn't challenged by the situation they're in, but they say they are, and you sort of have to take their word for it.
Wait, John, are you saying Katniss Everdeen isn't challenged by the situation she's in? In the book, she totally says she is. And in the movie, it totally looks like she is.
If I say I have trouble opening a soda, but you see me drinking a soda, how much trouble did I really experience? You took my word for it. I told you rather than showed you that I had a problem.
Yes, it's the old show-versus-tell problem again, this time in a new minty flavor. Let's break this down.
What defines a Super-Protagonist?
Main characters are supposed to experience trouble and difficulty along their path through the plot. It's supposed to be a challenge to them, to inspire/force/require them to change states from however they were at the beginning of the story to however they're meant to be at the end. A Super-Protagonist coasts through the challenge, sure they get a scrape or a bruise here or there to prove their humanity or mortality or their toughness, but in the overall scheme of things, it's a scrape versus being beaten and bedraggled and really limping toward the finish line.
And that's Katniss?
Totally.
But does that mean you expect or want all characters to just barely scrape by?
No. I don't want all characters to just barely scrape by. I'm not asking for the global difficulty level of books to get jacked up to 'Hardcore' or 'Insane' mode, I'm just asking that the challenges be modulated for the character. Big, strong, smart, capable character? Then break out the big, powerful, brilliant, creative problems.
But...Katniss is a YA heroine and a model for girls, etc etc? Is this a sexist thing?
This has NOTHING to do with the gender of the character or the range of the readability of the book or the genre or anything like that. This has to do with the core ends of storytelling, and the ability of an author to imperil their characters appropriately, whoever they might be.
So the idea that Katniss has to leave her home, kill others and survive isn't dangerous?
Um, no. It's not.
Wha?
Well you see, Katniss is a hunter (or as I identified her, a 1st-level Ranger). So outdoor survival isn't a new skill for her. And it's not that she's set up to be a killer, she's far more interested in self-preservation than in an active killing spree (besides, that's for the badguys to do to prove that they're bad, because, like, murder is totes bad), so she's not really out of her element.
But she sacrifices herself to save her sister....
It's only sacrifice if she dies. Else she risks herself, and as I just said, sticking her in the woods, where she's far more comfortable than when she's ever anywhere else (this is really clubbed over our head in the movie), that's not a risk. It's sort of like asking me to risk myself by going and sitting in my house with a stack of books, my Xbox and an internet connection.
But it's noble.....
No it's not. She's a great character, she's driven, talented, capable and powerful, but we can't see the full breadth of her potential because she's not out of her natural element. She's not challenged by the environment or the situation once the Game starts...her challenge came before she reached the woods, when she was back in the City and had to deal with the Game set up. But the book wasn't about Katniss-in-the-City, this was about Katniss-being-Katniss, doing-Katniss-things-that-just-happen-to-be-the-things-she's-good-at-already. Ho hum.
So how is she Super, exactly?
Okay I'll spell it out:
i. Her "struggle" occurs in her native environment.
ii. It's repeatedly made clear that she'll have access to her preferred weapon/tool.
iii. It's repeatedly said by other characters that she has a good/great/the best chance of surviving.
iv. Her knowledge (something unknown to other people, but something she acquired being herself) of berries sets up the conclusion. This wasn't knowledge she learned during THIS struggle, this was knowledge she came in with.
v. Even when she is out of her element, she's put into situations where she is clearly superior to others (she gets the Penthouse, she receives the most oohs and ahhs from the audience while interviewed, she makes the most striking impression).
vi. She says rather emphatically "she's not scared", when fear would be a natural reaction to oh-now-I-have-to-kill-23-teenagers-on-tv-and-not-die-trying.
But how is that a bad thing? I liked the series!
It's not a "bad" thing. The book/thought/movie police aren't going to come to your house and take away your ability to enjoy the experience, I'm just saying that writers need to be careful not to let themselves get drunk on the brew of their own protagonists.
Are you talking about character balance?
Partially, yes. But it goes deeper than that. This isn't just about making sure there's a flaw to counteract every positive you grant the character.
It's okay, I've given my super-smart, strong, attractive lead character a horrific mental disorder and/or drug addiction! Problem solved, right?
No....that's sort of exactly the problem.
Imagine a scale from -10 to +10. The character starts at 0, the center, and when you list the positive abilities or attributes, you move the character positively up the scale.
0 ---------> +4
(for example)
And every time you give your character a flaw or a drawback or a hindrance or penalize them in some way, you slide that character back negatively so the overall effect is a dramatically lower state -
-8 <--------- +4
(still with me?)
Which has the added complication of meaning you have to overcome that negative state when the story climaxes to prove the character positive overall
-8 ---------> + X
(because you want your character to succeed and end on an up-note)
Now the tendency here is say, 'Oh but my character is so awesome, she's no longer believable, so I'll offset these mega bonuses with a super huge negative!' So that your sporty, independent, intelligent, outspoken, attractive female star now has cooties, agoraphobia and....really bad cramps or something.
Look: You don't have to swing the pendulum that far back to offset the positives. You don't need to -7 the character just to make us like them. We'll like the character for the SUM of the positives and negatives, but that means you have to show us both sides and trust us to make our own decisions.
Wait, what do I have to do?
You (the author) have to trust us (the readers) to make up our own minds about your character(s) after you present us the character(s).
But what if I want to hold something back from the reader for later?
If that "something" is skill or knowledge or something, be careful, it may come across as convenient (i.e. Your character knows just the right fact about a shoe print). If that "something is backstory, be careful, because it may change the way some readers respond to the character. (i.e. We finally learn the reason Character Bro is a douchebag, and it's different than our opinions, therefore we will make hyperbolic statements on the interwebs and rage at you!!)
I'm not saying that every story needs to spell out EVERY facet of a character for the reader. You, author, can pick and choose what you want to say and how you want to say it, but I'm cautioning you that the idea of "sum to date" (what the reader knows at whatever their relative "present" moment is) is how they judge the character - and it can be unfair to ask them to wait for stories down the road to hold off on passing judgement, especially if you spend a lot of the story cementing an idea that this character is pretty much an unstoppable force in your created universe.
But, I want the readers to love this character!
Yes, we all want that. We all want readers to love our characters, but we'll love them all the more when we see them pushed to their limits, overcome obstacles we didn't know they could and take on bigger odds to make themselves more heroic.
If you play it safe with your character, you're doing us a disservice as readers (we won't get to know the character fully) and you're doing a disservice to yourself (you're not testing yourself as best you can as a writer). If you think your character is so original and so "out of the box", ask yourself how big the box is. And how much of that box does the reader know about at any given time.
But I'm scared. What if I suck? Or fail or get it wrong?
That's sort of what makes writing hard, but worthwhile. If you do it everyday, if you commit to it, you'll get better at it. That's about the best I can tell you without getting all ranty or raining on your parade.
What can I learn from Katniss as a character?
Well, a lot, if you like physically strong and capable female protagonists with a skillset and mindset to overcome obstacles. Slightly less if you want to use her for an intelligence study (there are characters in other books admittedly older, more experienced and smarter), and slightly less than that if you want to use her for an emotional study (there are characters who experience and demonstrate a wider swath of emotions more intensely and more visibly and more acutely). But you'll get far more if you learn the pitfalls.
I. Risk includes taking the character out of their comfort zone. Like all the way out. Nero Wolfe left the brownstone (under protest, but he did); Sherlock Holmes (especially in the modern version) struggled more with people than casework; Captain America was a paragon in the 1940s, but lost in a sea of individualism in the modern era.
II. Your character does not need to be nearly flawless to be liked. Katniss has "a voice birds go silent to hear" and "a beauty enhanced by what's inside". Those are pretty high watermarks for a character. You don't need to be the best ever just to be liked (it comes off desperate and fearful on the part of the author when you've made characters that are too perfect).
III. Your character does not need to be mega-super-flawed to be realistic. You don't need to take that super skilled character and give them crippling Asperger's. Nor do you need to make them the angstiest-girl-in-high-school-like-OMG-why-won't-Edward-like-notice-me. Remember the number line, you don't need the character to 'zero' out. You need the character just end up positive if you want a positive ending, or negative if you want a negative ending.
IV. When in doubt, SHOW us the situation and SHOW us the character's responses and reactions, rather than tell us what they're thinking. Let the reader draw their own conclusions (which you can't control anyway), and stop dictating to us what 'we're supposed to think/feel' even if you're worried about us 'getting it right'. Paint for us the picture, and we'll 'get it', but yes, that means you (author) have to do some work and demonstrate your skill and your craft. Sorry, them's the tradeoff.
Anything else?
Yeah, when you make the movie version of your book, stop shaking the damned camera.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)